An Overview and Prospect on Taxonomy of the Genus Populus

doi:10.7525/j.issn.1673-5102.2023.02.001

Abstract

Abstract:

Since Linnaeus established the genus Populus， many taxonomic studies have been carried out about it and some taxonomic systems have been proposed， while the taxonomy of Populus is still in the stage of traditional morphological classification around the world. Although the taxonomic hierarchy of ‘genus-section-species’ is adopted in many countries， in which has Populus plant distributed， there are great differences in the classification of species， subspecies and varieties. The taxonomists of China and the United States are the representatives of splitter and lumper respectively， and there is a huge gap in poplar classification between them， but each has advantages and disadvantages. Even in China， there are still many problems to be solved. The existing phylogenetic studies about the genus Populus provide useful information to taxonomic revision， but the actual contribution is small yet. The ultimate aim on poplar classification is to establish a unified taxonomic system based on phylogeny in the world. It requires a comprehensive classification based on both population and the concepts of integrated species， which integrates morphology， ecology， biogeography， genomic bioinformatics and evolutionary biology.

Key words: Populus, taxonomy, taxonomic revision, phylogeny, overview

CLC Number:

S792.11

Xueqin WAN, Yujie SHI, Jinliang HUANG, Jiaxuan MI, Yu ZHONG, Fan ZHANG, Lianghua CHEN. An Overview and Prospect on Taxonomy of the Genus Populus[J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2023, 43(2): 161-168.

References

1	洪德元.生物多样性事业需要科学、可操作的物种概念［J］.生物多样性，2016，24（9）：979-999.
1	HONG D Y.Biodiversity pursuits need a scientific and operative species concept［J］.Biodiversity Science，2016，24（9）：979-999.
2	黄普华.中国植物分类学发展之我见［J］.植物研究，2019，39（6）：970-971.
2	HUANG P H.My personal opinionon plant taxonomy in China［J］.Bulletin of Botanical Research，2019，39（6）：970-971.
3	ECKENWALDER J E.Taxonomic signal and noise in multivariate interpopulational relationships in Populus mexicana（Salicaceae）［J］.Systematic Botany，1996，21（3）：261-271.
4	ECKENWALDER J E.Systematics of Populus L.（Salicaceae） in southwestn North America with special reference to sect. Aigeiros Duby［D］.California：University of California，1977.
5	FANG Z F， ZHAO S D， SKVORTSOV A K.Flora of China，Vol.4［M］.Beijing：Science Press，1999：139-274.
6	孙岱阳.内蒙杨属二新种和六新变种［J］.南京林业大学学报（自然科学版），1986（4）：109-117.
6	SUN D Y.Two new species and six new varieties of Populus from Inner Mongolia［J］.Journal of Nanjing Forestry University（Natural Science Edition），1986（4）：109-117.
7	赵能，刘军.中国西南地区杨属的分类学研究（Ⅰ）［J］.武汉植物学研究，1991，9（3）：229-238.
7	ZHAO N， LIU J.Taxonomic studies on Populus L. in southwestern China（Ⅰ）［J］.Journal of Wuhan Botanical Research，1991，9（3）：229-238.
8	赵能，刘军.中国西南地区杨属的分类学研究（Ⅱ）［J］.武汉植物学研究，1994，12（3）：225-232.
8	ZHAO N， LIU J.Taxonomic studies on Populus L. in southwestern China（Ⅱ）［J］.Journal of Wuhan Botanical Research，1994，12（3）：225-232.
9	赵能，刘军，龚固堂.杨亚科植物的分类与分布［J］.武汉植物学研究，2009，27（1）：23-40.
9	ZHAO N， LIU J， GONG G T.On the classification and distribution of the subfamily Populoideae（Salicaceae）［J］.Journal of Wuhan Botanical Research，2009，27（1）：23-40.
10	WU H N， YAO D， CHEN Y H，et al. De novo genome assembly of Populus simonii further supports that Populus simonii and Populus trichocarpa belong to different sections［J］.Genes\|Genomes\|Genetics，2020，10（2）：455-466.
11	DE CANDOLLE A P， DE CANDOLLE A P， DUBY J é.Botanicon gallicum；seu，synopsis plantarum in flora gallica descriptarum［M］.Paris：Desray，1828.
12	SPACH E.Revisio Populorum［J］.Annales des Sciences Naturelles：Botanique：seconde série，1841，15：30-33.
13	陈振峰，曲式曾.西北地区杨属的数量分类［J］.植物研究，1989，9（4）：115-129.
13	CHEN Z F， QU S Z.A numericl taxonomy of the genus Populus from northwestern China［J］.Bulletin of Botanical Research，1989，9（4）：115-129.
14	DODE L A.Extraits d’une monographie inédite du genre Populus ［M］.Boston：Harvard University，1905.
15	赵能，龚固堂，刘军.杨柳科植物的分类与分布［J］.四川林业科技，1998（4）：10-21.
15	ZHAO N， GONG G T， LIU J.On the classification and distribution of the family Salicaceae［J］.Journal of Sichuan Forestry Science and Technology，1998（4）：10-21.
16	赵良能，龚固堂，刘军.杨树起源与进化的探讨［J］.四川林业科技，2016，37（1）：4-12.
16	ZHAO L N， GONG G T， LIU J.On the origin and evolution of the poplars［J］.Journal of Sichuan Forestry Science and Technology，2016，37（1）：4-12.
17	WANG Y C， HUANG J， LI E Z，et al.Phylogenomics and biogeography of Populus based on comprehensive sampling reveal deep-level relationships and multiple intercontinental dispersals［J］.Frontiers in Plant Science，2022，13：813177.
18	SARGENT C S.Plantae Wilsonianae： an enumeration of the woody plants collected in western China for the Arnold arboretum of Harvard university during the years 1907，1908 and 1910［M］.Cambridge：The University press，1917：33.
19	HAINES H H.On two new species of Populus from Darjeeling［J］.Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society，1906，37（262）：407-409.
20	DOWELD A B.Nomenclatural novelties and taxonomic changes for extant and fossil Populus（Salicaceae）［J］.Kew Bulletin，2017，72（3）：46.
21	王战，董世林.杨属植物新分类群（Ⅰ）［J］.东北林学院植物研究室汇刊，1979，4（1）：17-29.
21	WANG Z， DONG S L.New taxa of Populus（Ⅰ）［J］.Bulletin of Botanical Research，1979，4（1）：17-29.
22	赵能.四川及其邻近地区杨柳科植物分类的研究（Ⅲ）［J］.四川林业科技，1994，15（2）：1-11.
22	ZHAO N.Taxonomic study on Salicaceae in Sichuan and its adjacent regions（Ⅲ）［J］.Journal of Sichuan Forestry Science and Technology，1994，15（2）：1-11.
23	赵能，刘军.西藏的杨柳科树木［J］.四川林业科技，2001，22（4）：1-18.
23	ZHAO N， LIU J.The family Salicaceae in Tibet［J］.Journal of Sichuan Forestry Science and Technology，2001，22（4）：1-18.
24	LIU S Y， ZHANG L， SANG Y P，et al.Demographic history and natural selection shape patterns of deleterious mutation load and barriers to introgression across Populus genome［J］.Molecular Biology and Evolution，2022，39（2）：msac008.
25	于兆英，张明理，徐炳声，等.杨属的分支分析［J］.植物研究，1990，10（1）：69-76.
25	YU Z Y， ZHANG M L， XU B S，et al.Cladistic analysis of Populus ［J］.Bulletin of Botanical Research，1990，10（1）：69-76.
26	FORD M E M.A study of the evolutionary history of the genus，Populus L.（Salicaceae）［D］.Colorado：University of Colorado，2004.
27	CERVERA M T， STORME V， SOTO A，et al.Intraspecific and interspecific genetic and phylogenetic relationships in the genus Populus based on AFLP markers［J］.Theoretical and Applied Genetics，2005，111（7）：1440-1456.
28	WAN X Q， ZHANG F， ZHONG Y，et al.Study of genetic relationships and phylogeny of the native Populus in Southwest China based on nucleotide sequences of chloroplast trnT-trnF and nuclear DNA［J］.Plant Systematics and Evolution，2013，299（1）：57-65.
29	ZHANG L， WANG M C， MA T，et al.Taxonomic status of Populus wulianensis and P.ningshanica（Salicaceae）［J］.PhytoKeys，2018（108）：117-129.
30	HAMZEH M， DAYANANDAN S.Phylogeny of Populus（Salicaceae） based on nucleotide sequences of chloroplast TRNT-TRNF region and nuclear rDNA［J］.American Journal of Botany，2004，91（9）：1398-1408.
31	卫尊征，郭丽琴，张金凤，等.利用trnL-F序列分析杨属树种的系统发育关系［J］.北京林业大学学报，2010，32（2）：27-33.
31	WEI Z Z， GUO L Q， ZHANG J F，et al.Phylogenetic relationship of Populus by trnL-F sequence analysis［J］.Journal of Beijing Forestry University，2010，32（2）：27-33.
32	LIU X， WANG Z S， SHAO W H，et al.Phylogenetic and taxonomic status analyses of the abaso section from multiple nuclear genes and plastid fragments reveal new insights into the North America origin of Populus（Salicaceae）［J］.Frontiers in Plant Science，2017，7：2022.
33	HAN X M， WANG Y M， LIU Y J.The complete chloroplast genome sequence of Populus wilsonii and its phylogenetic analysis［J］.Mitochondrial DNA Part B，2017，2（2）：932-933.
34	ZHANG L M， SHANG C， DU F K，et al.Chloroplast phylogenomic analyses maternal relationships among sections in the genus Populus ［J］.Biochemical Systematics and Ecology，2017，70：132-140.
35	ZONG D， ZHOU A P， ZHANG Y，et al.Characterization of the complete chloroplast genomes of five Populus species from the western Sichuan plateau，southwest China：comparative and phylogenetic analyses［J］.PeerJ，2019，7：e6386.
36	GAO K， LI J， KHAN W U，et al.Comparative genomic and phylogenetic analyses of Populus section Leuce using complete chloroplast genome sequences［J］.Tree Genetics & Genomes，2019，15（3）：1-12.
37	ZHOU S L， XU C， LIU J，et al.Out of the Pan‐Himalaya：evolutionary history of the Paeoniaceae revealed by phylogenomics［J］.Journal of Systematics and Evolution，2021，59（6）：1170-1182.
38	LAMICHHANEY S， BERGLUND J， ALMéN M S，et al.Evolution of Darwin’s finches and their beaks revealed by genome sequencing［J］.Nature，2015，518（7539）：371-375.
39	EDELMAN N B， FRANDSEN P B， MIYAGI M，et al.Genomic architecture and introgression shape a butterfly radiation［J］.Science，2019，366（6465）：594-599.
40	LIU S L， WESTBURY M V， DUSSEX N，et al.Ancient and modern genomes unravel the evolutionary history of the rhinoceros family［J］.Cell，2021，184（19）：4874-4885.
41	万雪琴，张帆，钟宇，等.中国西南地区乡土杨树基因资源的保护与利用［J］.林业科学，2009，45（4）：139-144.
41	WAN X Q， ZHANG F， ZHONG Y，et al.Conservation and application of the genetic resource of native poplars in southwest China［J］.Scientia Silvae Sinicae，2009，45（4）：139-144.
42	WAN X Q， ZHANG F.An overview of Populus genetic resources in southwest China［J］.The Forestry Chronicle，2013，89（1）：79-87.
43	张德兴.为什么在物种概念上难以达成共识？［J］.生物多样性，2016，24（9）：1009-1013.
43	ZHANG D X.Why is it so difficult to reach a consensus in species concept？［J］.Biodiversity Science，2016，24（9）：1009-1013.
44	刘建全.“整合物种概念”和“分化路上的物种”［J］.生物多样性，2016，24（9）：1004-1008.
44	LIU J Q.“The integrative species concept” and “species on the speciation way” ［J］.Biodiversity Science，2016，24（9）：1004-1008.
45	陈家宽.居群、物种与生物多样性［J］.生物多样性，2016，24（9）：1000-1003.
45	CHEN J K.Population，species and biodiversity［J］.Biodiversity Science，2016，24（9）：1000-1003.
46	SCHLICK-STEINER B C， STEINER F M， SEIFERT B，et al.Integrative taxonomy：a multisource approach to exploring biodiversity［J］.Annual Review of Entomology，2010，55：421-438.

[1]	Zixuan REN, Ling ZHAO, Jiawen ZHAO, Qinghe WANG, Hongxiang YIN. Infraspecific taxa of Paris fargesii Franch. [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2023, 43(4): 505-519.
[2]	Qin TIAN, Chengyan SHAO, Hanning DUAN, Chenxuan YANG, Lu LI. Morph-anatomy of Leaf and Taxonomic Insights of Eight Viola species from Yunnan,China [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2023, 43(3): 447-460.
[3]	Yongchang LU, Xin ZHANG, Luyan ZHANG, Jiuli WANG. Complete Chloroplast Genome Structure and Characterization of Syringa villosa subsp. wolfii [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2023, 43(1): 120-130.
[4]	Qinghua WANG, Xiao’ao ZHENG, Yong JIANG, Yu JIA. Orthotrichum tortifolium Lewinsky(Orthotrichaceae, Bryophyta), a Bhutan Moss New to China [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2022, 42(5): 721-725.
[5]	Bojia WEI, Xuewen ZHANG, Youfang WANG, Jiancheng ZHAO, Min LI. Morphology and Taxonomic Significance of Pseudoparaphyllia in Brachytheciaceae (Bryophyta) [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2022, 42(5): 733-740.
[6]	Xiaolei MA, Liukun JIA, Qian CAO, Shilong CHEN, Qingbo GAO. Numerical Taxonomy on Saxifraga diversifolia Complex(Saxifragaceae) [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2022, 42(4): 536-543.
[7]	Yu ZHANG, Xu SU, Yuping LIU, Tao LIU, Changyuan ZHENG, Dandan SU, Yanan WANG, Ting LÜ. Characteristics of Complete Chloroplast Genome and Phylogenetic Analysis of Rhodiola himalensis (Crassulaceae) [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2022, 42(4): 602-612.
[8]	Mingze XIA, Faqi ZHANG, Xiaofeng CHI, Shuang HAN, Shilong CHEN. Evolutionary Analysis of Chloroplast Genome of Parnassia [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2022, 42(4): 626-636.
[9]	Jun LI, Yaping DUAN, Xiuzhen CAI, Ting WANG, Baihan PAN. Application of Cuticular Micromorphology of the Cuticle of Pinus Needles in Taxonomy [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2022, 42(3): 341-351.
[10]	Dandan SU, Yuping LIU, Tao LIU, Changyuan ZHENG, Yu ZHANG, Yanan WANG, Na QIN, Xu SU. Structure of Chloroplast Genome and its Characteristics of Sphaerophysa salsula [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2022, 42(3): 446-454.
[11]	Zhenghai Chen, Wenyuan Xie, Yifei Lu, Shenglong Liu, Xiaofeng Jin. New findings of the Genus Lonicera L. in Zhejiang Province [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2022, 42(1): 1-11.
[12]	Yan-Ci LI, Nai-Feng FU, Jia-Zhi SUN, Yan XIAO, Jian-Guo CAO, Dai-Ke TIAN. Intraspecific Phenotypic Diversity in Begonia grandis [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2021, 41(5): 775-788.
[13]	Qing-Hua WANG, Qiang HE, Yu JIA. Orthotrichum revolutum(Orthotrichaceae, Bryophyta), an Endemic Species to China, Rediscovered after 123 Years [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2021, 41(4): 481-487.
[14]	Qian CAO, Long-Hua XU, Jiu-Li WANG, Fa-Qi ZHANG, Shi-Long CHEN. Molecular Phylogeny of Subtribe Swertiinae [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2021, 41(3): 408-418.
[15]	Yan-Ping WANG, Lu LI, Chen-Xuan YANG, Yan LUO, Qing-Qing LI. Pollinia Morphology of 14 Species in Dendrobium(Orchidaceae) and Taxonomic Significance [J]. Bulletin of Botanical Research, 2021, 41(1): 12-25.