Multi-temporal NDVI analysis using UAV images of tree crowns in a northern Mexican pine-oak forest

doi:10.1007/s11676-023-01639-w

Abstract

Abstract:

The use of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV) for forest monitoring has grown significantly in recent years, providing information with high spatial resolution and temporal versatility. UAV with multispectral sensors allow the use of indexes such as the normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), which determines the vigor, physiological stress and photosynthetic activity of vegetation. This study aimed to analyze the spectral responses and variations of NDVI in tree crowns, as well as their correlation with climatic factors over the course of one year. The study area encompassed a 1.6-ha site in Durango, Mexico, where Pinus cembroides, Pinus engelmannii, and Quercus grisea coexist. Multispectral images were acquired with UAV and information on meteorological variables was obtained from NASA/POWER database. An ANOVA explored possible differences in NDVI among the three species. Pearson correlation was performed to identify the linear relationship between NDVI and meteorological variables. Significant differences in NDVI values were found at the genus level (Pinus and Quercus), possibly related to the physiological features of the species and their phenology. Quercus grisea had the lowest NDVI values throughout the year which may be attributed to its sensitivity to relative humidity and temperatures. Although the use of UAV with a multispectral sensor for NDVI monitoring allowed genera differentiation, in more complex forest analyses hyperspectral and LiDAR sensors should be integrated, as well other vegetation indexes be considered.

Key words: Multispectral images, Normalized difference, Vegetation index, Phenology, Unmanned aerial vehicles, Multitemporal analysis

José Luis Gallardo-Salazar, Marcela Rosas-Chavoya, Marín Pompa-García, Pablito Marcelo López-Serrano, Emily García-Montiel, Arnulfo Meléndez-Soto, Sergio Iván Jiménez-Jiménez. Multi-temporal NDVI analysis using UAV images of tree crowns in a northern Mexican pine-oak forest[J]. JOURNAL OF FORESTRY RESEARCH, 2023, 34(6): 1855-1867.

References 77

1	Abdalla A, Elmahal A (2016) Augmentation of vertical accuracy of digital elevation models using Gaussian linear convolution filter. In: 2016 Conference of Basic Sciences and Engineering Studies SGCAC. Khartoum, Sudan, pp 206–210
2	Aboutalebi M, Torres-Rua AF, Kustas WP, Nieto H, Coopmans C, McKee M. Assessment of different methods for shadow detection in high-resolution optical imagery and evaluation of shadow impact on calculation of NDVI, and evapotranspiration. Irrig Sci, 2019, 37: 407-429, DOI
3	Acosta-Hernández AC, Padilla-Martínez JR, Hernández-Díaz JC, Prieto-Ruiz JA, Goche-Telles JR, Nájera-Luna JA, Pompa-García M. Influence of climate on carbon sequestration in conifers growing under contrasting hydro-climatic conditions. Forests, 2020, 11: 11, DOI
4	Aragones D, Rodriguez-Galiano VF, Caparros-Santiago JA, Navarro-Cerrillo RM. Could land surface phenology be used to discriminate mediterranean pine species?. Int J Appl Earth Obs Geoinf, 2019, 78: 281-294, DOI
5	Avtar R, Suab SA, Syukur MS, Korom A, Umarhadi DA, Yunus AP. Assessing the influence of UAV altitude on extracted biophysical parameters of young oil palm. Remote Sens, 2020, 12: 18, DOI
6	Barbasiewicz A, Widerski T, Daliga K. The analysis of the accuracy of spatial models using photogrammetric software: agisoft photoscan and Pix4D. E3S Web Conf, 2018, 26: 12, DOI
7	Beucher S, Meyer F. Dougherty ER. The morphological approach to segmentation: the watershed transformation. Mathematical Morphology in Image Processing, 2018 CRC Press 433-481, DOI
8	Bickford IN, Fulé PZ, Kolb TE. Growth sensitivity to drought of co-occurring Pinus spp. along an elevation gradient in northern Mexico. West North Am Nat, 2011, 71: 338-348, DOI
9	Boon MA, Drijfhout AP, Tesfamichael S. Comparison of a fixed-wing and multi-rotor UAV for environmental mapping applications: a case study. Int Arch Photogramm Remote Sens Spat Inf Sci, 2017, 42: 47-54, DOI
10	Bose AK, Scherrer D, Camarero JJ, Ziche D, Babst F, Bigler C, Bolte A, Dorado-Liñán I, Etzold S, Fonti P, Forrester DI, Gavinet J, Gazol A, de Andrés EG, Karger DN, Lebourgeois F, Lévesque M, Martínez-Sancho E, Menzel A, Neuwirth B, Nicolas M, Sanders TGM, Scharnweber T, Schröder J, Zweifel R, Gessler A, Rigling A. Climate sensitivity and drought seasonality determine post-drought growth recovery of Quercus petraea and Quercus robur in Europe. Sci Total Environ, 2021, 784: 147222, DOI
11	Brede B, Calders K, Lau A, Raumonen P, Bartholomeus HM, Herold M, Kooistra L. Non-destructive tree volume estimation through quantitative structure modelling: comparing UAV laser scanning with terrestrial LIDAR. Remote Sens Environ, 2019, 233: 111355, DOI
12	Brovkina O, Cienciala E, Surový P, Janata P. Unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV) for assessment of qualitative classification of Norway spruce in temperate forest stands. Geo-Spatial Inf Sci, 2018, 21: 12-20, DOI
13	Burdziakowski P. Evaluation of open drone map toolkit for geodetic grade aerial drone mapping. Int Multidiscip Sci GeoConference-SGEM, 2017, 17: 101-109, DOI
14	Choudhry H, O’Kelly G (2018) Precision forestry: a revolution in the woods. https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/paper-forest-products-and-packaging/our-insights/precision-forestry-a-revolution-in-the-woods# /. [Accessed on 06.01.2021]
15	Clerici N, Weissteiner CJ, Gerard F. Exploring the use of MODIS NDVI-based phenology indicators for classifying forest general habitat categories. Remote Sens, 2012, 4: 1781-1803, DOI
16	Crutzen PJ, Brauch HG. A pioneer on atmospheric chemistry and climate change in the anthropocene, 2016 Cham Springer
17	D’Odorico P, Besik A, Wong CYS, Isabel N, Ensminger I. High-throughput drone-based remote sensing reliably tracks phenology in thousands of conifer seedlings. New Phytol, 2020, 226: 1667-1681, DOI
18	de Castro AI, Shi Y, Maja JM, Peña JM. UAV for vegetation monitoring: overview and recent scientific contributions. Remote Sens, 2021, 13(11): 2139, DOI
19	Dong XY, Zhang ZC, Yu RY, Tian QJ, Zhu XC. Extraction of information about individual trees from high-spatial-resolution UAV-acquired images of an orchard. Remote Sens, 2020, 12(1): 133, DOI
20	Ecke S, Dempewolf J, Frey J, Schwaller A, Endres E, Klemmt HJ, Tiede D, Seifert T. UAV-based forest health monitoring: a systematic review. Remote Sens, 2022, 14: 3205, DOI
21	Fawcett D, Bennie J, Anderson K. Monitoring spring phenology of individual tree crowns using drone-acquired NDVI data. Remote Sens Ecol Conserv, 2021, 7: 227-244, DOI
22	Feng L, Chen S, Zhang C, Zhang Y, He Y. A comprehensive review on recent applications of unmanned aerial vehicle remote sensing with various sensors for high-throughput plant phenotyping. Comput Electron Agric, 2021, 182: 106033, DOI
23	Gallardo-Salazar JL, Pompa-García M. Detecting individual tree attributes and multispectral indices using unmanned aerial vehicles: applications in a pine clonal orchard. Remote Sens, 2020, 12: 24, DOI
24	Gallardo-Salazar JL, Pompa-García M, Aguirre-Salado CA, López-Serrano PM, Meléndez-Soto A. Drones: tecnología con futuro promisorio en la gestión forestal. Rev Mex Ciencias For, 2020, 11(61): 27-50, DOI
25	Garrity SR, Vierling LA, Smith AMS, Falkowski MJ, Hann DB. Automatic detection of shrub location, crown area, and cover using spatial wavelet analysis and aerial photography. Can J Remote Sens, 2008, 34: S376-S384, DOI
26	Ghebrezgabher MG, Yang T, Yang X, Wang X, Khan M. Extracting and analyzing forest and woodland cover change in Eritrea based on Landsat data using supervised classification. Egypt J Remote Sens Sp Sci, 2016, 19: 37-47, DOI
27	Gómez-Baggethun E, de Groot R, Lomas PL, Montes C. The history of ecosystem services in economic theory and practice: from early notions to markets and payment schemes. Ecol Econ, 2010, 69: 1209-1218, DOI
28	González-Cásares M, Pompa-García M, Camarero JJ. Differences in climate–growth relationship indicate diverse drought tolerances among five pine species coexisting in Northwestern Mexico. Trees, 2017, 31: 531-544, DOI
29	Groos AR, Bertschinger TJ, Kummer CM, Erlwein S, Munz L, Philipp A. The potential of low-cost UAV and open-source photogrammetry software for high-resolution monitoring of alpine glaciers: a case study from the Kanderfirn (Swiss Alps). Geosciences, 2019, 9(8): 356, DOI
30	Grybas H, Congalton RG. A comparison of multi-temporal RGB and multispectral UAS imagery for tree species classification in heterogeneous new hampshire forests. Remote Sens, 2021, 13(13): 2631, DOI
31	Hajek P, Link RM, Nock C, Bauhus J, Gebauer T, Gessler A, Kovach K, Messier C, Paquette A, Saurer M, Scherer-Lorenzen M, Rose L, Schuldt B. Mutually inclusive mechanisms of drought-induced tree mortality. Glob Change Biol, 2020, 28: 3365-3378, DOI
32	Herrera-Soto G, González-Cásares M, Marín Pompa-García J, Camarero RS-M. Growth of Pinus cembroides Zucc. in response to hydroclimatic variability in four sites forming the species latitudinal and longitudinal distribution limits. Forests, 2018, 9(7): 440, DOI
33	Holopainen M, Vastaranta M, Hyyppä J. Outlook for the next generation’s precision forestry in Finland. Forests, 2014, 5: 1682-1694, DOI
34	Huang S, Tang L, Hupy JP, Wang Y, Shao G. A commentary review on the use of normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) in the era of popular remote sensing. J Forestry Res, 2021, 32: 1-6, DOI
35	Jing L, Hu B, Noland T, Li J. An individual tree crown delineation method based on multi-scale segmentation of imagery. ISPRS J Photogramm Remote Sens, 2012, 70: 88-98, DOI
36	Kovalev A, Soukhovolsky V. Analysis of forest stand resistance to insect attack according to remote sensing data. Forests, 2021, 12: 1188, DOI
37	Larsen M, Eriksson M, Descombes X, Perrin G, Brandtberg T, Gougeon FA. Comparison of six individual tree crown detection algorithms evaluated under varying forest conditions. Int J Remote Sens, 2011, 32: 5827-5852, DOI
38	Lechner AM, Foody GM, Boyd DS. Applications in remote sensing to forest ecology and management. One Earth, 2020, 2: 405-412, DOI
39	Lehmann J, Nieberding F, Prinz T, Knoth C. Analysis of unmanned aerial system-based CIR images in forestry—a new perspective to monitor pest infestation levels. Forests, 2015, 6: 594-612, DOI
40	Li J, Wang S, Qin N, Liu X, Jin L. Vegetation index reconstruction and linkage with drought for the source region of the Yangtze river based on tree-ring data. Chinese Geogr Sci, 2021, 31: 684-695, DOI
41	Lindsay JB. Whitebox GAT: a case study in geomorphometric analysis. Comput Geosci, 2016, 95: 75-84, DOI
42	Lu H, Fan TX, Ghimire P, Deng L. Experimental evaluation and consistency comparison of UAV multispectral minisensors. Remote Sens, 2020, 12(16): 2542, DOI
43	Magney TS, Eitel JUH, Huggins DR, Vierling LA. Proximal NDVI derived phenology improves in-season predictions of wheat quantity and quality. Agr Forest Meteorol, 2016, 217: 46-60, DOI
44	Mancino G, Nolè A, Ripullone F, Ferrara A. Landsat TM imagery and NDVI differencing to detect vegetation change: assessing natural forest expansion in Basilicata, southern Italy. Iforest, 2014, 7: 75-84, DOI
45	Maselli F. Monitoring forest conditions in a protected Mediterranean coastal area by the analysis of multiyear NDVI data. Remote Sens Environ, 2004, 89: 423-433, DOI
46	McDowell NG, Allen CD, Anderson-Teixeira K, Aukema BH, Bond-Lamberty B, Chini L, Clark JS, Dietze M, Grossiord C, Hanbury-Brown A, Hurtt GC, Jackson RB, Johnson DJ, Kueppers L, Lichstein JW, Ogle K, Poulter B, Pugh TAM, Seidl R, Turner MG, Uriarte M, Walker AP, Xu C. Pervasive shifts in forest dynamics in a changing world. Science, 2020, DOI
47	Meneses-Tovar CL. NDVI as indicator of degradation. Unasylva, 2011, 62: 39-46
48	Michez A, Piégay H, Lisein J, Claessens H, Lejeune P. Classification of riparian forest species and health condition using multi-temporal and hyperspatial imagery from unmanned aerial system. Environ Monit Assess, 2016, 188: 146, DOI
49	Mitchell JJ, Glenn NF, Anderson MO, Hruska RC, Halford A, Baun C, Nydegger N (2012) Unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) hyperspectral remote sensing for dryland vegetation monitoring. In: 2012 4th workshop on hyperspectral image and signal processing: evolution in remote sensing (WHISPERS). pp 1–10
50	Modica G, Messina G, de Luca G, Fiozzo V, Praticò S. Monitoring the vegetation vigor in heterogeneous citrus and olive orchards. A multiscale object-based approach to extract trees’ crowns from UAV multispectral imagery. Comput Electron Agric, 2020, 175: 105500, DOI
51	Monteiro LA, Sentelhas PC, Pedra GU. Assessment of NASA/POWER satellite-based weather system for Brazilian conditions and its impact on sugarcane yield simulation. Int J Climatol, 2018, 38: 1571-1581, DOI
52	Open Drone Map (2021) Awesome. Drone. Software. https://opendronemap.org/. [Accessed on 02.08.2021]
53	Pacheco A, Camarero JJ, Pompa-García M, Battipaglia G, Voltas J, Carrer M. Growth, wood anatomy and stable isotopes show species-specific couplings in three Mexican conifers inhabiting drought-prone areas. Sci Total Environ, 2020, 698: 134055, DOI
54	Parrot (2021) Support−Parrot Sequoia. https://support.parrot.com/us/support/products/parrot-sequoia. [Accessed on 06.01.2021]
55	Pedrono M, Locatelli B, Ezzine-de-Blas D, Pesche D, Morand S, Binot A. Torquebiau E. Impact of climate change on ecosystem services. Climate Change and Agriculture Worldwide, 2016 Netherlands, Dordrecht Springer 251-261, DOI
56	Perevochtchikova M, Flores JÁH, Marín W, Flores AL, Bueno AR, Negrete IAR. Systematic review of integrated studies on functional and thematic ecosystem services in Latin America, 1992–2017. Ecosystem Services, 2019, 36: 100900, DOI
57	Pesaresi S, Mancini A, Casavecchia S. Recognition and characterization of forest plant communities through remote-sensing NDVI time series. Diversity, 2020, 12: 313, DOI
58	Plowright, A, Roussel J (2020) ForestTools: analyzing remotely sensed forest data. R package version 0.2.5. https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/ForestTools/index.html. [Accessed on 06.01.2021]
59	Pompa-García M, Zúñiga-Vásquez J, Treviño-Garza E. Pompa-García M, Camarero JJ. A dendro-spatial analysis in tree growth provides insights into forest. Latin American Dendroecology, 2020 Cham Springer 247-262, DOI
60	Pompa-García M, González-Cásares M, Gazol A, Camarero JJ. Run to the hills: forest growth responsiveness to drought increased at higher elevation during the late 20th century. Sci Total Environ, 2021, 772: 145286, DOI
61	Popescu SC, Wynne RH. Seeing the trees in the forest. Photogramm Eng Remote Sens, 2004, 70: 589-604, DOI
62	Pravalie R, Sîrodoev I, Peptenatu D. Detecting climate change effects on forest ecosystems in Southwestern Romania using Landsat TM NDVI data. J Geogr Sci, 2014, 24: 815-832, DOI
63	QGIS Core Team (2021) A free open source. Geogr. Inf. Syst. https://qgis.org/. [Accessed on 06.01.2021]
64	Qiu L, Jing LH, Hu BX, Li H, Tang YW. A new individual tree crown delineation method for high resolution multispectral imagery. Remote Sens, 2020, 12(3): 585, DOI
65	R Core Team (2021) The R project for statistical computing. https://www.r-project.org/. [Accessed on 06.01.2021]
66	Ramli MF, Tahar KN. Homogeneous tree height derivation from tree crown delineation using Seeded Region Growing (SRG) segmentation. Geo Spatial Inf Sci, 2020, 23: 195-208, DOI
67	Rodríguez-Catón M, Villalba R, Morales M, Srur A. Influence of droughts on Nothofagus pumilio forest decline across northern Patagonia Argentina. Ecosphere, 2016, 7: e01390, DOI
68	Sankey TT, McVay J, Swetnam TL, McClaran MP, Heilman P, Nichols M. UAV hyperspectral and lidar data and their fusion for arid and semi-arid land vegetation monitoring. Remote Sens Ecol Con, 2018, 4: 20-33, DOI
69	Socorro González-Elizondo M, Martha González-Elizondo JA, Tena-Flores LR-G, Lorena López-Enríquez I. Vegetación de la sierra madre occidental, México: una síntesis. Acta Botanica Mexicana, 2022, DOI
70	Sona G, Pinto L, Pagliari D, Passoni D, Gini R. Experimental analysis of different software packages for orientation and digital surface modelling from UAV images. Earth Sci Informatics, 2014, 7: 97-107, DOI
71	Stackhouse P, Westberg D, Hoell J, Chandler WS, Zhang T (2015) Surface meteorology and Solar Energy (SSE) Release 6.0 Methodology Version 3.2.0 June 2, 2016. https://dokumen.tips/download/link/sse-release-60-methodology.html. [Accessed on 06.01.2021]
72	Thapa S, Garcia Millan VE, Eklundh L. Assessing forest phenology: a multi-scale comparison of near-surface (UAV, spectral reflectance sensor, Phenocam) and satellite (MODIS, Sentinel-2) remote sensing. Remote Sens, 2021, 13: 1597, DOI
73	Torresan C, Benito Garzón M, O’Grady M, Robson TM, Picchi G, Panzacchi P, Tomelleri E, Smith M, Marshall J, Wingate L, Tognetti R, Rustad LE, Kneeshaw D. A new generation of sensors and monitoring tools to support climate-smart forestry practices. Can J Forest Res, 2021, 51: 1751-1765, DOI
74	Villanueva Daz J, Cerano Paredes J, Rosales Mata S, Arrocena Lpez JC, Stahle DW, Ruiz Corral JA, Martnez Sifuentes AR. Variabilidad hidroclimática reconstruida con anillos de árboles para la cuenca alta del Río Mezquital, Durango. Rev Mex Ciencias Agrícolas, 2014, 10: 1897-1912
75	Wang Z, Lyu L, Liu W, Liang H, Huang J, Zhang QB. Topographic patterns of forest decline as detected from tree rings and NDVI. CATENA, 2021, 198: 105011, DOI
76	Wong CYS, D’Odorico P, Bhathena Y, Arain MA, Ensminger I. Carotenoid based vegetation indices for accurate monitoring of the phenology of photosynthesis at the leaf-scale in deciduous and evergreen trees. Remote Sens Environ, 2019, 233: 111407, DOI
77	Zhang J, You S, Gruenwald L (2015) Efficient parallel zonal statistics on large-scale global biodiversity data on GPUs. In: BigSpatial’15: Proceedings of the 4th international ACM SIGSPATIAL WORKSHOP on analytics for big geospatial data. pp 35–44

[1]	Kobra Shojaeizadeh, Mahmoud Ahmadi, Abbasali Dadashi-Roudbari. Contribution of biophysical and climate variables to the spatial distribution of wildfires in Iran [J]. JOURNAL OF FORESTRY RESEARCH, 2023, 34(6): 1763-1775.
[2]	Siyuan Chen, Liangyun Liu, Lichun Sui, Xinjie Liu. Improving GPP estimates by partitioning green APAR from total APAR in two deciduous forest sites [J]. JOURNAL OF FORESTRY RESEARCH, 2023, 34(4): 915-927.
[3]	Fabrina Bolzan Martins, Mábele de Cássia Ferreira, Flávia Fernanda Azevedo Fagundes, Gabriel Wilson Lorena Florêncio. Thermal and photoperiodic requirements of the seedling stage of three tropical forest species [J]. JOURNAL OF FORESTRY RESEARCH, 2023, 34(1): 209-220.
[4]	Marín Pompa-García, J. Julio Camarero, Michele Colangelo. Different xylogenesis responses to atmospheric water demand contribute to species coexistence in a mixed pine–oak forest [J]. JOURNAL OF FORESTRY RESEARCH, 2023, 34(1): 51-62.
[5]	Yanbo Hu, Raul Antonio Sperotto, Georgios Koubouris, Srđan Stojnić, Nacer Bellaloui. Tree ecophysiology in the context of climate change [J]. JOURNAL OF FORESTRY RESEARCH, 2023, 34(1): 1-5.
[6]	Tetsuto Sugai, Wataru Ishizuka, Toshihiro Watanabe. Landscape gradient of autumn photosynthetic decline in Abies sachalinensis seedlings [J]. JOURNAL OF FORESTRY RESEARCH, 2023, 34(1): 187-195.
[7]	Rafaela Lanças Gomes, Marília Caixeta Sousa, Felipe Girotto Campos, Carmen Sílvia Fernandes Boaro, José Raimundo de Souza Passos, Gisela Ferreira. Near-infrared leaf reflectance modeling of Annona emarginata seedlings for early detection of variations in nitrogen concentration [J]. JOURNAL OF FORESTRY RESEARCH, 2023, 34(1): 269-282.